The natron chemical theory — molten natron softening granite for workers to pound with stone balls — doesn't hold up under scrutiny. Penetration depth would be only 1-3mm even with strong acids. No sodium silicate (water glass) residue exists at the site despite the theory requiring it. The massive charcoal requirements would be nearly impossible in a desert environment over 5,000 years. Experimental tests also failed to match real mark characteristics. The Unfinished Obelisk, Egypt
Natron Chemical Theory Ineffective for Granite Excavation
EgyptTheory
Key facts
- Natron theory proposes molten natron reacts with granite to create water glass, then workers pound with dolerite balls
- Molten natron penetration into granite is minimal - strong acids penetrate only 1-3mm under favorable conditions
- Chemical reaction would leave visible color changes and sodium silicate (water glass) residue at the site
- No sodium silicate residue exists at Aswan quarry despite the claim
- Method would require enormous amounts of charcoal in a desert environment with scarce timber for 5,000 years
- Experimental natron marks do not resemble the real Aswan scoop marks in size, shape, or edge characteristics
Site mentioned
Sources
The Granite "Mistake" - The Natron Theorynatrontheory.com
Which means if you can work on granite with molten natron, you can also work on these stone types as well. It's a total misconception to believe that ...
School History Books Are Wrong Or “A Better Way to Make Ancient ...tatiana-colligan.medium.com
A theory about etching stones, including granite, with Natron Salt, also called Soda Ash, also called Sodium Carbonate, also Na2CO3.
The Natron Theorynatrontheory.com
Natron is a kind of salt which was abundant in the Nile valley (now depleted). People have been hand-picking and collecting it in baskets since ancient times.
Was this story useful?
Keep exploring
Every site on this page sits on the globe, and the people who research them are on the Discord.
3D Globe · Sites by country · Story Archive · Research Library · Weekly Journal · Search
AI-generated text · images from the original sources · always verify with the sources.