Archaeologist Susan Sherratt argues Homer's epics should not be read literally

Have We Been Looking for Odysseus' Ithaca in the Wrong Place?
Source: Have We Been Looking for Odysseus' Ithaca in the Wrong Place? by Inside Archaeology

Susan Sherratt argues that armor and weapons in the Iliad match archaeological periods from 1600, 1200 and 800 BC—a thousand-year mash-up. She also argues that Homer mislocated the eight rivers around Troy. The video presents the epics as oral traditions compiled over centuries and then revised during Pisistratus's tyranny in the late sixth century BC.

Key facts

  • Susan Sherratt argued that armor and weapons in the Iliad reflect archaeological periods from 1600 BC, 1200 BC, and 800 BC.
  • Sherratt argued that Homer misplaced the eight rivers around Troy and described their flow directions incorrectly.
  • The epics were oral traditions passed down for centuries before being written down and were probably compiled from multiple poems.
  • Sherratt argued that the text was modified during Pisistratus's tyranny in the late sixth century BC, giving Athens and Athena greater prominence.
  • In the Iliad, basileus is used for kings, whereas the Bronze Age title wanax is attested in Linear B; the titles refer to different forms of authority.
  • Sherratt contrasted Bronze Age Mycenaean palaces, major administrative complexes associated with Linear B tablets, with the simpler houses described in Homer.
  • Adrienne Mayor popularized the proposal that the Cyclops myth was inspired by ancient Greeks finding elephant or hippopotamus skulls.
  • Sherratt argued that the epics were probably written in the Iron Age and cited isotope analysis indicating little animal protein despite Homer's constant feasts.

Related stories

Sources

abdn.ac.uk
antigonejournal.com
Susan SHERRATT - Department of Archaeologyresearchgate.net
Insights from the Study of Sword Combat in The Iliadrepositories.lib.utexas.edu
Susan Sherratten.wikipedia.org
Shields in Iliad and the Use of Metalskosmossociety.org
Reading the texts': archaeology and the Homeric questionacademia.edu
Susan Sherratt and John Bennet (eds). Archaeology and the ...archaeopresspublishing.com
Was this story useful?

← All stories

Keep exploring

Every site on this page sits on the globe, and the people who research them are on the Discord.

3D Globe · Sites by country · Story Archive · Research Library · Weekly Journal · Search

AI-generated text · images from the original sources · always verify with the sources.