Homer's geography remains debated. Phthia was an ancient city or district in Thessaly and the Myrmidons' home in the Iliad; its exact location remains uncertain, with Pharsala a proposed identification. The video argues that Ithaca's archaeology does not match Homer, that Thebes lacks the fortifications Homer portrays, and that Gla's engineering feats were beyond Roman capability. The walled Thebes in Book 6 is Egyptian, distinct from Boeotian Thebes; Gla itself was a vast Mycenaean acropolis larger than Mycenae and is absent from the poem. The video appears to mislabel its c. 900 BC date for Sparta's foundation as AD.
The video argues Homer made geographic and chronological errors
Key facts
- Phthia was an ancient city or district in Thessaly and the Myrmidons' home in the Iliad; its exact archaeological location remains debated.
- Pharsala is a proposed, not universally accepted, identification of Phthia. The suggestion that Homer directly drew on its Cyclopean walls remains speculative.
- The video argues that surviving archaeology on Ithaca does not match Homer's descriptions; this is the presenter's claim, not a conclusion established by the supplied results.
- The Iliad refers to both Boeotian Thebes and the Egyptian Thebes explicitly described as walled in Book 6. The original post does not distinguish them.
- Gla was an enormous second-millennium BC Mycenaean acropolis, substantially larger than Mycenae, and is not mentioned in the Iliad.
- The claim that Gla's engineering works were beyond Roman capability is the video's interpretation.
- The video gives Sparta's foundation as around 900 BC but apparently labels it AD. Homer's poems are generally dated to the eighth century BC.
Sources
Phthia - Wikipediaen.wikipedia.org
The river Spercheios was associated with Achilles, and at Iliad 23.144 Achilles states that his father Peleus had vowed that Achilles would dedicate a lock ...
Achilles - Wikipediaen.wikipedia.org
Achilles was raised in Phthia along with his childhood companion Patroclus ... Phthius, from his birthplace, Phthia; Podarkes, "swift-footed", from the ...
Achilles | Patroclus, Myth, Significance, Trojan War, & Factsbritannica.com
According to Homer, Achilles was brought up by his mother at Phthia with his inseparable companion Patroclus. Later non-Homeric tales suggest ...
Achilles :: The Trojan War Hero - Greek Mythologygreekmythology.com
Achilles was the son of Peleus, king of Thessalian Phthia, and Thetis, a sea-goddess. Even though he did grow up to become the greatest of all Greek heroes, for ...
Phthia, Greece - Ancient City, Home of Achilles & Myrmidonstimelessmyths.com
Phthia, an ancient Mycenaean city in Thessaly, Greece, holds significant historical and mythological importance as the home of Achilles and ...
(DOC) RESURRECTION OF ACHILLES HOMELAND AND ...academia.edu
Phthia, Achilles' homeland, is identified primarily with ancient Pharsala in southeastern Thessaly. The Iliad, composed by Homer, is foundational to European ...
The mystery of Homer's Phthia: Ten years Research in ...councilofachilles.org
Achilles was born and grew to manhood in Phthia, though for a time at the island of Skyros. His mother Thetis has a temple said to be located at Thetidio, a ...
The potential of ancient Phthia as a cultural heritage centre.researchgate.net
The research focuses on ancient Phthia in the region of Thessaly, central Greece. For centuries the birthplace of Achilles itself remains silent ...
Was this story useful?
Keep exploring
Every site on this page sits on the globe, and the people who research them are on the Discord.
3D Globe · Sites by country · Story Archive · Research Library · Weekly Journal · Search
AI-generated text · images from the original sources · always verify with the sources.