Surovell paper challenges Monteverde dating using volcanic lens evidence

500 BC - 1 AD
A Catastrophe Killed the Ice Age Giants
Source: A Catastrophe Killed the Ice Age Giants by The Cosmic Summit

Site mentioned

📍 Monteverde🌍 Show on the globe

Todd Surovell (University of Wyoming) argues in Science that a volcanic lens beneath Monteverde dates to ~11,000 years old, making the landform only ~8,000 years old. If correct, pre-Clovis occupation is stratigraphically impossible. He also doubts the site's artifacts and hearths are anthropogenic. Proposed fix: new cores directly at Monteverde 2.

Key facts

  • Todd Surovell of the University of Wyoming published a geomorphological study arguing a volcanic lens beneath the Monteverde site dates to approximately 11,000 years ago.
  • Surovell's argument contends the landform the site sits on is approximately 8,000 years old, making older-than-Clovis occupation stratigraphically impossible.
  • Surovell did not take geological cores at the primary Monteverde 2 site, instead sampling at other points along the surrounding ravine.
  • Surovell questions whether the artifacts and hearths are anthropogenic.
  • The proposed resolution is to take new geological cores directly at Monteverde 2 and conduct comparative stratigraphic analysis with Surovell's samples from up the ravine.
  • Surovell's paper was published in Science.

More about Monteverde

Sources

Monte Verde fieldwork resets age of famous South American ...phys.org
Surovell et al, A mid-Holocene age for Monte Verde challenges the timeline of human colonization of South America, Science (2026). DOI ...
A mid-Holocene age for Monte Verde challenges the ... - Sciencescience.org
Surovell et al. ,. A mid-Holocene age for Monte Verde challenges the timeline of human colonization of South America.Science391,1283-1288 ...
30 researchers publish scathing critiques of study that questioned ...livescience.com
One of the main findings in the Surovell study was the presence of a unique layer of ash known as the Lepué Tephra, which blanketed the area ...
Archaeological site in Chile upends theory of how humans ...theguardian.com
Discovery at Monte Verde puts north-to-south expansion theory back at centre of heated debate on continent's human history.
A later debut for humans | Sciencescience.org
Although Monte Verde grounded chronologies for early colonization of the Americas for decades, the landscape is different now, with more sites ...
Was this story useful?

← All stories

Keep exploring

Every site on this page sits on the globe, and the people who research them are on the Discord.

3D Globe · Sites by country · Story Archive · Research Library · Weekly Journal · Search

AI-generated text · images from the original sources · always verify with the sources.