Todd Surovell (University of Wyoming) argues in Science that a volcanic lens beneath Monteverde dates to ~11,000 years old, making the landform only ~8,000 years old. If correct, pre-Clovis occupation is stratigraphically impossible. He also doubts the site's artifacts and hearths are anthropogenic. Proposed fix: new cores directly at Monteverde 2.
Surovell paper challenges Monteverde dating using volcanic lens evidence

Site mentioned
📍 Monteverde🌍 Show on the globe
Key facts
- Todd Surovell of the University of Wyoming published a geomorphological study arguing a volcanic lens beneath the Monteverde site dates to approximately 11,000 years ago.
- Surovell's argument contends the landform the site sits on is approximately 8,000 years old, making older-than-Clovis occupation stratigraphically impossible.
- Surovell did not take geological cores at the primary Monteverde 2 site, instead sampling at other points along the surrounding ravine.
- Surovell questions whether the artifacts and hearths are anthropogenic.
- The proposed resolution is to take new geological cores directly at Monteverde 2 and conduct comparative stratigraphic analysis with Surovell's samples from up the ravine.
- Surovell's paper was published in Science.
Sources
Monte Verde fieldwork resets age of famous South American ...phys.org
Surovell et al, A mid-Holocene age for Monte Verde challenges the timeline of human colonization of South America, Science (2026). DOI ...
A mid-Holocene age for Monte Verde challenges the ... - Sciencescience.org
Surovell et al. ,. A mid-Holocene age for Monte Verde challenges the timeline of human colonization of South America.Science391,1283-1288 ...
30 researchers publish scathing critiques of study that questioned ...livescience.com
One of the main findings in the Surovell study was the presence of a unique layer of ash known as the Lepué Tephra, which blanketed the area ...
Archaeological site in Chile upends theory of how humans ...theguardian.com
Discovery at Monte Verde puts north-to-south expansion theory back at centre of heated debate on continent's human history.
A later debut for humans | Sciencescience.org
Although Monte Verde grounded chronologies for early colonization of the Americas for decades, the landscape is different now, with more sites ...
Was this story useful?
Keep exploring
Every site on this page sits on the globe, and the people who research them are on the Discord.
3D Globe · Sites by country · Story Archive · Research Library · Weekly Journal · Search
AI-generated text · images from the original sources · always verify with the sources.