Marcel’s claim that 99.99999% of evaporating saline lakes precipitate natron first is overstated. Natron is hydrated sodium carbonate; table salt is sodium chloride, which is highly soluble and commonly precipitates late. The Bonneville Salt Flats in Utah are mostly sodium chloride, and Los Colorados in Mexico is another halite-rich salt flat. Halite-rich deposits show that sodium chloride can dominate, but without sequence data they do not prove which salt precipitated first. 🧂
Salt Precipitation Order Overstated: Natron Is Not Always First

Key facts
- Marcel claimed that 99.99999% of evaporating saline lakes precipitate natron first; that extraordinary figure is his claim, not an established statistic.
- In a simplified sodium carbonate–sodium chloride system, sodium carbonate generally reaches saturation before the more soluble NaCl. In real brines, precipitation order depends on the full salt composition and temperature.
- Natron is sodium carbonate decahydrate (Na2CO3·10H2O), not sodium chloride.
- The Utah site is the Bonneville Salt Flats, not Bonavville. The BLM says the flats are composed mostly of sodium chloride, and other sources identify halite there.
- The Mexican site is Los Colorados, Mexico.
- Halite-rich deposits show that sodium chloride can dominate saline-lake deposits, but their presence alone does not establish which salt precipitated first.
Sources
Bonneville Salt Flatsen.wikipedia.org
Bonneville Salt Flatsvisitutah.com
Bonneville Salt Flatsutah.com
Was this story useful?
Keep exploring
Every site on this page sits on the globe, and the people who research them are on the Discord.
3D Globe · Sites by country · Story Archive · Research Library · Weekly Journal · Search
AI-generated text · images from the original sources · always verify with the sources.