Retraction of Beyond Protocol Giza paper leads to litigation and validation demands

Pyramid complex3000 - 1500 BC
Evaluating the Biondi SAR Method with Trevor Grassi LIVE
Source: Evaluating the Biondi SAR Method with Trevor Grassi LIVE by DeDunking

Site mentioned

📄 Giza Necropolis🗺️ More sites in Egypt🌍 Show on the globe

The Beyond Protocol Giza SAR paper was retracted after authors couldn't answer specific questions; the presenters posted their exchange with the authors' attorney. The journal reportedly demanded comparison with seismic sensors or another validated reference method. Developer Filippo Carta, who has 90+ papers, wants a commercial licence so others can run the software, and has imaged the Titanic wreck with it. ⚖️📡

Key facts

  • A paper presenting the Beyond Protocol's Giza SAR survey was retracted by its journal after the authors were unable to provide the specific answers requested for scientific debate; the presenters posted the litigation document exchanged with the authors' attorney.
  • The journal's response, quoted in the stream, states that a new measurement method requires rigorous experimental validation and independent confirmation, and that its results must be compared with those obtained using an established reference method, including simultaneous seismic sensor measurements or another independently validated technique.
  • The presenters note that a separate paper describing the same technology at a different location was left published while the Great Pyramid paper was retracted, and they point to a similar push for retractions over the Ganjong Padang work.
  • The Beyond Protocol's developer, Filippo Carta, works with a military organisation, has more than 90 scientific papers to his name and is seeking a commercial licence for the desktop software so the method can be used by others.
  • The method is described as processing SAR data from four separate satellite providers, co-registering multiple scans and comparing differences in surface topography across them, rather than sending a penetrating signal into the ground, and as using Python scripts for the processing work.
  • Test scans by the same developer have imaged the wreck of the Titanic on the seabed, posted publicly in August.

More about Giza Necropolis

Sources

What Really Lies Beneath the Pyramids ...papers.ssrn.com
Retraction: Beyond the Curriculum: Exploring Perception of ...cureus.com
Synthetic Aperture Radar Doppler Tomography Reveals ...mdpi.com
Bombshell Great Pyramid of Giza Study Retractednewsweek.com
Retraction Note: A modified multilocus sequence typing ... - PMCpmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov
Was this story useful?

← All stories

Keep exploring

Every site on this page sits on the globe, and the people who research them are on the Discord.

3D Globe · Sites by country · Story Archive · Research Library · Weekly Journal · Search

AI-generated text · images from the original sources · always verify with the sources.