Radiocarbon dating supports Great Pyramid chronology; video’s other claims remain unproven

Cave Structures1500 - 500 BC
Illegitimate Scholar & DeDunking Mock Debunker Archaeologists
Source: Illegitimate Scholar & DeDunking Mock Debunker Archaeologists by DeDunking

Site mentioned

📄 Derinkuyu Underground City🗺️ More sites in Türkiye🌍 Show on the globe

Radiocarbon dating broadly supports the conventional chronology of the Great Pyramid. AERA reported older-than-expected results, including a 374-year discrepancy, but concluded that the samples placed the pyramid in the historical Old Kingdom. The 2010 study quoted by the BBC likewise found that radiocarbon dating supported the chronology of Egypt’s Old, Middle and New Kingdoms.

The video argues that Bayesian modelling was used to force later dates and that the Edgar Cayce Foundation and David Koonce funded the work to disprove the written record; the cited results do not substantiate that interpretation or motive. It also argues that Derinkuyu was excavated from the top down. Byzantine Christian artifacts there show later activity and cannot by themselves date the first tunnels.

Archaeology is a scientific discipline, although particular interpretations remain open to revision.

Key facts

  • AERA reported radiocarbon results consistent with the Great Pyramid’s historical Old Kingdom date, although it also reported a 374-year older-than-expected result that may reflect older material or contamination.
  • The 2010 study reported by the BBC concluded that radiocarbon dating supported the conventional chronology of Egypt’s Old, Middle and New Kingdoms; it does not establish a systematic 200–300-year conflict with written records.
  • The video argues that Bayesian modelling was used to force later dates and that the Edgar Cayce Foundation and David Koonce funded the dating to disprove written records. The cited results do not establish that manipulation or funding motive.
  • The video argues that Derinkuyu has reversed stratigraphy. Byzantine Christian artifacts demonstrate Byzantine-period activity there, but do not by themselves date the original excavation of the tunnels.
  • Archaeology is a scientific discipline; the headline’s blanket description of it as pseudoscience is unsupported.

More about Derinkuyu Underground City

Sources

Radiocarbon Dates of Old and Middle Kingdom Monuments in Egyptresearchgate.net
The Curious Conflict Between Radiocarbon Dating and Early Egyptianarmstronginstitute.org
Carbon-14 dating, explained - UChicago Newsnews.uchicago.edu
An absolute chronology for early Egypt using radiocarbon dating ...pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov
Dating the Pyramids - Archaeology Magazine Archivearchive.archaeology.org
How Old Are the Pyramids?|AERAaeraweb.org
NOVA Online/Pyramids/How Old Are the Pyramids?pbs.org
Pyramidology and Radiocarbon: the Dating ...abdn.elsevierpure.com
Was this story useful?

← All stories

Keep exploring

Every site on this page sits on the globe, and the people who research them are on the Discord.

3D Globe · Sites by country · Story Archive · Research Library · Weekly Journal · Search

AI-generated text · images from the original sources · always verify with the sources.