1949 coffin radiocarbon dates had wide error margins

Pyramid complex3000 - 1500 BC
Radiocarbon Dating Hides Secrets In Ancient Egypt Carbon 14
Source: Radiocarbon Dating Hides Secrets In Ancient Egypt Carbon 14 by DeDunking

Site mentioned

📄 Giza Necropolis🗺️ More sites in Egypt🌍 Show on the globe

Willard Libby and James Arnold’s 1949 tests dated wood from Nefru’s coffin at 2625 ± 150 BC and from Djoser’s (Zoser’s) coffin at 2700 ± 200 BC. The point estimates were close to the then-used ranges of 2613–2589 BC and 2670–2640 BC, but the published uncertainties were far wider than 50 years. The 36- and 60-year differences therefore do not demonstrate 50-year accuracy. These were laboratory dates for coffin wood, including material associated with Saqqara, not a 50-year-accuracy study at Giza. Nefru was 4th Dynasty and Djoser 3rd; the Great Pyramids and Great Sphinx are generally assigned to the 4th Dynasty.

Key facts

  • Libby and Arnold’s 1949 paper reported conventional radiocarbon ages of 2625 ± 150 BC for Nefru’s coffin wood and 2700 ± 200 BC for Djoser’s (Zoser’s) coffin wood, not ±75 years.
  • The central estimates fell near the then-used chronological ranges of 2613–2589 BC and 2670–2640 BC. The 36- and 60-year offsets do not establish 50-year accuracy.
  • These were laboratory analyses of coffin wood, not a study demonstrating 50-year accuracy at Giza. Djoser was a 3rd-Dynasty ruler associated with Saqqara; Nefru was 4th Dynasty.
  • Egyptology generally assigns the three Great Pyramids at Giza and the Great Sphinx to the 4th Dynasty.
  • The 1949 figures are conventional radiocarbon ages; modern comparisons require calibration and archaeological context.

More about Giza Necropolis

Sources

cambridge.org
archive.archaeology.org
academia.edu
caeno.org
c14.arch.ox.ac.uk
In Libby's Test Tube, Radiocarbon Dating Understoodtexasbeyondhistory.net
Revisiting the first mummy investigated with X-ray in 1896 ...pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov
Radiocarbon dating of linen from an Egyptian mummyapo.ansto.gov.au
Was this story useful?

← All stories

Keep exploring

Every site on this page sits on the globe, and the people who research them are on the Discord.

3D Globe · Sites by country · Story Archive · Research Library · Weekly Journal · Search

AI-generated text · images from the original sources · always verify with the sources.