Video Presents Shaw’s Flood Hypothesis for Some North American Drumlins

Thousands of Drumlins Across North America Are Proof of a Flood That Defies All Known Science
Source: Thousands of Drumlins Across North America Are Proof of a Flood That Defies All Known Science by The Cosmic Summit

The video argues, citing John Shaw, that some North American drumlin fields formed during catastrophic, pressurized subglacial floods. Shaw introduced that hypothesis in 1989, but drumlin origins remain debated. His then-graduate student Jerome Lessemann documented swarms in British Columbia. A drumlin’s blunt end generally points upstream and its tapered end downstream, so coeval fields can reveal flow direction. The Livingstone Lake flood’s estimated peak discharge was about 84,000 m³/s—not 84,000 km³. The video interprets British Columbia orientations as evidence of flow from the north, but this does not prove one flood across North America or exclude glacial Lake Missoula.

Key facts

  • The video argues, citing John Shaw’s 1989 hypothesis, that pressurized subglacial meltwater floods formed some drumlin fields; drumlin origins in general remain debated.
  • John Shaw, a University of Alberta geomorphologist, introduced the flood hypothesis in his 1989 paper Drumlins and catastrophic subglacial floods.
  • Jerome Lessemann, then Shaw’s graduate student at the University of Alberta, documented drumlin swarms in British Columbia.
  • A drumlin’s blunt end generally faces upstream and its tapered end downstream, so its long-axis orientation can indicate paleoflow direction.
  • Large drumlin fields provide many flow-direction measurements, but their orientations alone do not prove that all the drumlins formed simultaneously.
  • The Livingstone Lake flood’s estimated peak discharge was about 84,000 m³/s—a flow rate—not a total volume of 84,000 km³.
  • The video interprets British Columbia drumlin orientations as evidence of flow from the north; this does not establish one flood across North America or exclude a separate glacial Lake Missoula flood.

Related stories

Sources

[PDF] Drumlin formation by subglacial meltwater erosionfaculty.washington.edu
This erosional theory is related to an earlier theory in which drumlins are held to result from the infilling of subglacial cavities. The unifying factor for ...
(PDF) Drumlin formation by subglacial meltwater - ResearchGateresearchgate.net
It is concluded that some drumlins are composed of preexisting sediment or bedrock left upstanding in ridges as a result of the removal of surrounding materials ...
Drumlins and catastrophic subglacial floods - ScienceDirect.comsciencedirect.com
Drumlins are associated with landforms related to such floods, and landscapes produced by outburst floods in extraglacial areas contain drumlin-like landforms.
The meltwater hypothesis for subglacial bedforms - ScienceDirect.comsciencedirect.com
This paper presents an historical and in places informal account of the meltwater hypothesis, which invokes enormous outburst floods for the formation of ...
Drumlin formation by subglacial meltwater erosioncdnsciencepub.com
It is concluded that some drumlins are composed of preexisting sediment or bedrock left upstanding in ridges as a result of the removal of surrounding materials ...
John Shaw Responds to: Drumlins and subglacial meltwater ...google.com
In the meltwater hypothesis vortices forming cavity fill drumlins are presumed to be on the scale of the landforms. Horseshoe vortices forming erosional ...
Drumlins and catastrophic subglacial floods - ADSgoogle.com
by J Shaw · 1989 · Cited by 206 — The flood hypothesis requires extensive subglacial lakes to have occurred beneath the Laurentide and Fennoscandian Ice Sheets which, if they existed, must have ...
Evidence for large-scale subglacial meltwater flood events ...google.com
John Shaw Flow-line patterns constructed from the orientation of drumlin long axes are used to infer two major subglacial meltwater floods in southern Ontario
Was this story useful?

← All stories

Keep exploring

Every site on this page sits on the globe, and the people who research them are on the Discord.

3D Globe · Sites by country · Story Archive · Research Library · Weekly Journal · Search

AI-generated text · images from the original sources · always verify with the sources.