Controversies and methodology flaws in the Shroud of Turin's 1988 carbon dating. Radiocarbon dating method was invented in the 1950s and initially required a handkerchief-size sample. Accelerator mass spectrometry (AMS), which can date threads, was invented in the late 1970s. The Shroud was radiocarbon dated in 1988, when the AMS method was only about 11 years old and considered unproven on cloth.
The 1988 Shroud of Turin radiocarbon dating remains controversial. The AMS method was only ~11 years old and unproven on cloth. Statisticians flagged suspicious methodology, with labs discarding outliers to reach 95% confidence (1260-1390). Raw data wasn't released until a 2017 FOIA request, 29 years later. 🧵
Key Facts
- Radiocarbon dating method was invented in the 1950s and initially required a handkerchief-size sample.
- Accelerator mass spectrometry (AMS), which can date threads, was invented in the late 1970s.
- The Shroud was radiocarbon dated in 1988, when the AMS method was only about 11 years old and considered unproven on cloth.
- A three-day planning meeting was held in Turin in 1986 with the cardinal; nearly all proposed protocols were ultimately ignored.
- Raw data was not released until a 2017 Freedom of Information Act request, 29 years after the dating.
- Statisticians found the methodology and statistics suspicious, noting that labs threw out outliers to achieve the 95% confidence factor.
- The dating placed the Shroud between 1260 and 1390 with 95% confidence, but without discarding outliers that figure could not be reached.
- The Shroud has been above ground since at least the 1350s, making it a poor candidate for C14 dating since the method works best on buried materials.
Source: He Says No Technology on Earth Could Recreate the Shroud by The Cosmic Summit